Their use by trainees, focused on ethical competence, provides the practical face of virtue ethics in medical education and practice. It suffered something of an eclipse during the early modern period, although it is still one of the three dominant approaches to normative ethics the others being deontology and consequentialism. Virtue ethics i virtue ethics is an ethical view originating in ancient greece which says that ethics is fundamentally about learning to live well. Forms of ve were set out by ancient greek and ancient chinese philosophers and can be found. Utilitarianism i the most common form of consequentialism is utilitarianism i utilitarianism combines consequentialism with the claim that the only valuable consequence is pleasure, and the only disvaluable consequence is pain. Most of these moral dilemmas are often analyzed using the principlebased approach which applies the four moral principles of justice, autonomy, beneficence, and nonmalificence. Oct 02, 2008 virtue ethics is person rather than action based. Agent based approaches generally derive their philosophical foundation from virtue ethics theory. In contrast to such popular, but bare and impersonal, principles as beneficence, nonmaleficence, and autonomy, the author employs an aristotelian approach to reintroduce three related virtues. Virtue theorists also emphasize the need for people to.
Virtue ethics, essentially eudaimonism, was the prevailing approach to ethical thinking in the ancient and medieval periods. Hursthouse combines the best of ancient greek wisdom with simple commonsense rare in philosophy in a way that is informed by the ethical texture of human nature and human life, resulting in a supremely clear and. Virtue ethics or virtue theory is an approach to ethics that emphasizes an individuals character as the key element of ethical thinking, rather than rules about the acts themselves or their consequences consequentialism there are three main strands of virtue ethics eudaimonism is the classical formulation of virtue ethics. Wisdom means a rational openmindedness, love of learning, and good judgment about the uncertainties of life. Starting with an overview of virtue ethics in the philosophical tradition of the west, beginning with aristotle, i discuss the contemporary revival of virtue ethics in the west and its critics. However, if nurses are to enter into the global dialogue about ethics, they must do more than practice ethics based simply on their personal opinions, their intuition, or the unexamined beliefs that are proposed by other people. It may, initially, be identified as the one that emphasizes the virtues. It is believed that a person with the strong character has imbibed emotional, intellectual, moral and social virtues to achieve the selfdiscipline. I what is required to be an excellent teacher is di erent than what is required to be an excellent soldier, because teachers and soldiers have di erent functions i thus, there are di erent virtues for teachers, for soldiers. Virtue ethics is not necessarily a completely rival. Virtuebased definition of virtuebased by medical dictionary. Virtue ethics, approach to ethics that takes the notion of virtue often conceived as excellence as fundamental. How one does what one does is as important as what one does. Virtue ethicists discuss the nature and definition of virtues and other related problems that focus on the consequences of action.
A virtue ethics approach to moral dilemmas in medicine. Michael slote calls them virtue focused and virtuebased theories. The final variety of virtue ethics that will be looked at is agent based virtue ethics as proposed by michael slote 1997. When using the quality principles approach, one should take the point of view that in living their. We may think it a good thing if people keep their promises and tell the truth even when. They say that actionbased ethical models focus on formulating moral rules, but fail to motivate or inspire people to be moral. Virtue ethics explores what is the ethical choice based upon your virtues, or what is morally right. In essence, the virtue in virtue ethics is defined as some desirable character trait, such as courage, that lies between two ext remes, such as rashness and cowardice.
Plato, 4th century bc a human virtue is a relatively stable character aspect that disposes a person to act in a benevolent way. But does this renewal of interest in the virtues have much to contribute to. Thus, the virtue ethical theories are based on the notion that developing a sound character is what the life is all about. Again, the focus of virtue ethics is on becoming a virtuous person rather than on individual actions. Virtue ethics, by contrast, focuses on the development of the character of the individual. Most of these moral dilemmas are often analyzed using the principle based approach which applies the four moral principles of justice, autonomy, beneficence, and nonmalificence. Virtue theory virtue ethics based on the ideas which is that morality involves producing excellent persons, who act well out of spontaneous goodness and serve as examples to inspire others ideal moral person should accumulate a range of virtues. The leadership virtues questionnaire article pdf available in consulting psychology journal practice and research 624. Even though that behavior is to be expected on the job, seeing examples of it at work can.
Principlebased ethical theories provide guides to action. Sep 19, 2018 virtue based ethical theories place less emphasis on which rules people should follow and instead focus on helping people develop good character traits, such as kindness and generosity. In essence, the virtue in virtueethics is defined as some desirable character trait, such as courage, that lies between two ext remes, such as rashness and cowardice. It can fulfill its function well if it has the virtues of sharpness, durability, etc. By practicing being honest, brave, just, generous, and so on, a person develops an honorable and moral character. It holds that the proper goal of human life is eudaimonia.
Identifying and choosing alternatives based on values and preferences. Virtue ethics lacks a decisionprocedure to help us make. Virtue ethics all the gold on the earth and under the earth is less precious than virtue. Teleological ethics such as the utilitarianism of john s. Frankena a critique of virtuebased ethics a virtue is a disposition, quality, habit etc not a principle or rule. Both teleological and deontological ethical theories are called deontic or actionbased theories of morality. The modern revival of a virtuebased ethical theory is generally credited to the publication in 1958 of elizabeth anscombes essay, modern moral philosophy, in which anscombe critiqued ethical theories grounded in concepts of duty and obligation, the ethics of should and ought 30.
These include how virtues are acquired, how they are applied in various real. Virtue ethics is primarily concerned with traits of character that are essential to human flourishing, not with the enumeration of duties. Judgment is exercised not through a set of rules, but as a result of possessing those dispositions or virtues that enable choices to be made about what is good and holding. Virtue ethics studies the character traits of good persons. There is some circularity to the logic of virtue ethics. Even though that behavior is to be expected on the job, seeing examples of it at work can make an employee standout from their colleagues. I have to say that agentbased theories seem more in accord with the spirit of virtue ethics. The virtuebased approach is a personal approach that is motivated by an individuals own character. Exploring how contemporary moral philosophy has tackled the issue of character.
Virtue theory and applied ethics article pdf available in south african journal of philosophy 212 december 2005 with 9,083 reads how we measure reads. Some argue that virtue ethics is circular and gives us no guidance on what to do. Thomas aquinas, we developed a rating instrument for assessing. Sandler environmental ethics see environmental ethics is the study of the ethical relationships between human beings and the natural environment, including the nonhuman individuals that populate and constitute it. The importance of virtue ethics in the irb marilyn c morris, jason z. Acts of promisekeeping and kindness have no moral worth if they dont spring from the right motives. If this happens, we say that a moral dilemma has occurred. Virtue ethics i the other major concept of virtue ethics is that of virtue. Philosophers such as aristotle explored what virtue ethics means and specifically what virtue. Loyalty is a virtue that is operative only when dealing with people or, perhaps, places with which one has an appropriate history. The character builds a substantive moral foundation for ones actions. Virtue ethics is a broad term for theories that emphasize the role of character and virtue in moral philosophy rather than decisions about the relative merits of doing ones duty deontology vs. Virtue ethics is also called agentbased or personality ethics. Generally, health care practitioners approach moral dilemmas based on two broad, divergent and.
Agentbased approaches generally derive their philosophical foundation from virtueethics theory. Utilitarianism, deontological, and virtue theory ethics. I a virtue is a trait which allows one to ful ll ones function well. Virtue ethics the journal seeks to promote ethical. In slotes words, an agentbased theory of right action treats the moral or ethical status of an action as entirely derivative from independent and fundamental ethicalaretaic facts or claims about the motives, dispositions, or inner life of moral individuals, slote, p.
P1 if aristotles virtue ethics is correct, then whether or. Ethics and virtue markkula center for applied ethics. This characterbased approach to morality assumes that we acquire virtue through practice. Process of sufficiently reducing uncertainty and doubt about alternatives to allow a reasonable choice to be made. While virtue ethics does share certain common targets. At times, the dynamic balance in the nursepatient interaction becomes so blurred that a choice between equally valid ethical outcomes or ideals, such as health, must be made. They say that action based ethical models focus on formulating moral rules, but fail to motivate or inspire people to be moral. Virtuebased ethical theory virtue theory dates back to the ancient greek philosophers, especially plato and aristotle. In considering the relationships, emotional sensitivities, and motivations that are unique to human society it provides a fuller ethical analysis and encourages more flexible and creative solutions than principlism or. Approaching ethical leadership from a characterological perspective, this study reports on the creation of the leadership virtues questionnaire lvq.
Indeed, it assists in transforming the professional conscience of whistleblowing into a practical, virtue based culture of self reporting and personal development. This theory is attracting increasing interest from business ethicists. Jul 23, 2010 in slotes words, an agentbased theory of right action treats the moral or ethical status of an action as entirely derivative from independent and fundamental ethicalaretaic facts or claims about the motives, dispositions, or inner life of moral individuals, slote, p. It is the quest to understand and live a life of moral character. Examples of virtue ethics an employee who displays ethical behavior at work based on the virtues they hold dear are often seen as more reliable and dependable by their superiors. A study in moral theory by alasdair macintyre, the nicomachean ethics by aristotle, dialogues and essays by. At the heart of the virtue approach to ethics is the idea of community. A virtue theorist insists there is no such thing as a manual that will tell us how to. People acting in this manner often do not simply follow rules blindly. Virtue ethics is currently one of three major approaches in normative ethics. It may, initially, be identified as the one that emphasizes the virtues, or moral character, in contrast to the approach that emphasizes duties or rules deontology or that emphasizes the consequences of actions consequentialism.
A virtue ethics for nursing is therefore concerned with the character of individual nurses and seeks ways to enable nurses to develop character traits appropriate for. Pdf virtue theory and applied ethics liezl l van zyl academia. Virtue ethics focuses on the bettering of agent of the action, and not just the rule or action itself, to create an ethical society visavis the development of more virtuous citizens as demonstrated by their virtuous actions. Another way to say this is that in virtue ethics, morality stems from the identity or character of the individual, rather than being a reflection of the actions or consequences thereof of the individual.
Virtue ethics focuses on the development of sound moral character rather than moral rules. I some utilitarians even allow for there to be quanti able units of pain and pleasure. If the positive consequences outweigh the negative ones then the action is morally proper. Criticism of actionbased models virtue ethicists criticize actionbased ethical models in a number of ways. Consequentialist theories on the other hand determine the value of an action on the grounds of a costbenefit analysis of its consequences. Virtues are character traits or habits of action which, according to virtue theory, define the moral person. Virtue ethics focuses on the benefits, or ethical personality, whereas deontology focuses on responsibilities or guidelines. Virtue ethics is an approach that focuses on character with the assumption that a person of good character will tend to behave in ways that are consistent with their character. Utilitarianism focuses on the repercussions of activities. He explained that virtue ethical theories are typically agentfocused. Virtue theory accepts the importance of intentions and. Virtue ethics, technology, and human flourishing oxford.
Utilitarianism, deontological, and virtue theory ethics free. I as we saw with mill, aristotle argues that there is only one. Traits of character must include the disposition to act and. Defining an ethical leader as one who adheres to the four cardinal virtues of prudence, fortitude, temperance, and justice, as discussed in the ancient texts of aristotle and st. A new form of agentbased virtue ethics springerlink.
Virtue ethics refers to a collection of normative ethical philosophies that place an emphasis on being rather than doing. Virtue ethics and its potential as the leading moral theory. Nurses are increasingly confronted with situations of moral difficulty, such as not to feed terminally ill patients, whistle blowing, or participation in termination of pregnancy. Pdf critics of virtue ethics have argued that its focus on character rather than action, as well as its rejection of universal rules of right action. Virtue ethics is a philosophy developed by aristotle and other ancient greeks.
The virtue of wisdom is perhaps the most basic virtue. Virtue ethics that is, the approach that might account for such suffering, meanwhile, has been relegated toat besta place on the sideline. Ethical theories organizational behavior rulebased or. The essay finishes with a discussion of possibilities for future research, arguing that virtue ethics offers us original ways to confront the kind of ethical dilemmas that. Criticism of action based models virtue ethicists criticize action based ethical models in a number of ways. Mill, understands ethics as based on the consequences in terms of happiness caused by actions 79.
Virtue ethics is also called agent based or personality ethics. An ethics that focuses on principles or duty is an ethic of doing frankena argues that both are necessary. This is because they focus entirely on the actions. While are three approaches are useful when examining ethical issues, i want to focus on the virtuebased approach specifically. Criticisms of aristotles virtue ethics an argument based on this objection. Virtue ethics is a framework that focuses on the character of the moral agent rather than the rightness of an action. However, both the rejection of rulebased ethics offered by ve, and the key place in virtuebased approaches for virtues, flourishing and practical wisdom.
Introduction to ethics in the world today, we are in the throes of a giant ethical leap that is essentially embracing all of humankind donahue, 1996, p. I we can give an easy model of the value of an action. A virtue is an environmentally responsive virtue if it is an excellent character trait whose field of operation includes some aspect of the natural environment. In this theory, it is believed that having a virtuous character leads to virtuous decisions. I the basis of virtue ethics is the idea of eudaimonia, which means \the good life or \life lived well or \ ourishing or \happiness. Riggio, weichun zhu, and christopher reina claremont mckenna college james a. These character traits will, in turn, allow a person to make the correct decisions later on in life. Virtue ethics is not necessarily a completely rival approach to deontology and consequentialism but part. It is defined as having knowledge of the basic truths of life, especially selfknowledge, and the ethical application of this knowledge to real life situations.
196 934 15 478 1182 1515 1587 1501 1367 1328 107 256 923 124 1033 665 624 927 782 696 1313 60 272 253 760 1408 1582 857 1003 704 699 497 106 351 805